An IRS notice arrives. Can you find what your firm decided three years ago?
A client forwards an IRS notice about a return your firm prepared three years ago. Where do you start?
The return itself is easy to pull up. The hard part is everything around it. Why was that item treated the way it was? What did the preparer rely on? Was the client told about any risk? If the person who prepared it has left, those answers may be gone.
Responding to an IRS notice at a glance
| What you need | Where small firms usually look | How long it takes |
|---|---|---|
| The filed return | Tax software | Minutes |
| Client documents | Portal or shared drive | Minutes to hours |
| Reasoning behind the position | Preparer's memory or email | Hours, or not at all |
| Authority relied on at the time | Rarely recorded | Re-research from scratch |
| Law as it stood for that tax year | Current sources, which may have changed | Easy to get wrong |
Why older returns are harder than they look
- The law may have changed since. The response has to rely on the rules for the tax year in question, not today's rules.
- The people may have changed. Seasonal staff and departures mean the original preparer may not be available.
- The timeline is fixed. Notices come with response deadlines, so slow reconstruction costs real money and stress.
The IRS generally has three years from filing to assess additional tax, and longer in some situations. See IRC §6501. That window is exactly why the reasoning behind a return needs to outlive busy season.
Prepare for notices before they arrive
- Keep a short position note for any non-routine item on a return.
- Record the authority and the tax year it was applied to.
- Store notes with the client and year, where someone would look first.
- Note what the client was told, especially about risk.
- Keep notes at least as long as the return can be examined.
When the notice is already here
- Confirm which tax year and which item the notice is about.
- Pull the return and any position note for that item.
- Check the rules that applied to that tax year, not the current version.
- Draft the response from the original reasoning, updated only where facts differ.
- Save the response with the client file, so the next notice starts from here.
Frequently asked questions
What if there is no note for the position? Reconstruct it from the client documents and the authority for that tax year, then write the note so it exists next time.
Can we rely on current IRS guidance for an older year? Only if it applied to that year. Check effective dates before citing anything.
Do notices usually concern old returns? Notices often concern a prior-year return rather than the one you just filed, which is why year-specific records matter.
How Factagora.tax helps
Factagora.tax is AI tax research for any tax year. It answers with the law that applied to the return, not just today's law, and can keep your firm's earlier research with its sources, so a notice response can start from what the firm actually relied on.
Want to see it on your own client questions? Get early access. Early access is free.